Duane Marais Attorneys Logo

Criminal Law

Criminal Proceedings
  • Criminal proceedings are initiated by a complainant who either witnessed or was the victim of a crime committed against the complainant, by initiating a complaint at a police station or other Government institution clothed with the powers to investigate criminal complaints.

    The Police or Goverment institution will then investigate the complaint and refer the complaint to the Prosecuting Authority to make a decision as to whether a prima facie crime was committed, that should be prosecuted.

    There are various methods through which a suspect can be brought before Court, including inter alia an Indictment, Summons, Notice or through arresting the suspect.

    The police may detain a suspect for up to forty-eight (48) hours before it should bring the suspect before a Court to stand trial. In practice, the aforesaid forty-eight (48) hours refers to roughly two (2) Court days, which means that weekends and public holidays are excluded from this interpretation of days.

    A suspect, who now becomes the Accused person, has a right to formally apply for bail, make use of the various pre-trial procedures or set the matter down for trial.

    At trial an Accused person has various options at their disposal including inter alia pleading not guilty, pleading guilty, pleading various other forms of pleadings or enter agreement with the State pertaining to the Accused’s conviction and / or sentencing arrangements.

    An accused can be found guilty or not guilty at trial. If found guilty of convicting a crime, an Accused person shall be sentenced by Court. An Accused person has a right to Appeal or Review the aforesaid finding.

Duane Marais Attorneys Bail Applications
  • You do not have to stay in prison until brought to court for a first appearance. Your right to an attorney and the right not to be deprived of your freedom without just cause are protected by both the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1957 (CPA) and the Constitution. Also bear in mind that according to the Constitution you are presumed innocent until proven guilty.

Duane Marais Attorneys Unlawful Arrest and Detention
  • f you‘ve been arrested and you believe that your arrest was unlawful, you may be able to claim compensation for your wrongful arrest.

    Arrests can be considered unlawful if the arresting officers did not have probable cause to believe that you committed a crime, if they used excessive force during the arrest, or if you were detained for an unreasonable amount of time.

    The duty of the police is to prevent, combat and investigate crime, to maintain public order, to uphold the law and to protect and secure the people and property within the borders of South Africa. The police are an institution designed to protect innocent citizens, but there have been many reports of corrupt officers breaking the law. While it is understandable that police may sometimes make quick decisions in order to prevent crime, mistakes can easily be made.

    The South African Police Department is allowed to use force where necessary to execute their duties, but the force used must always be proportional to the circumstances. If police officers use excessive and unnecessary force, they may be guilty of a criminal offense. Unlawful arrest occurs when a police officer detains someone without probable cause or a warrant. Probable cause exists when there is a reasonable belief that a person has committed a crime. A warrant is a court order authorizing law enforcement to make an arrest.

    A police officer may only arrest a person without a warrant if they witness the person commit a crime, or if they have reasonable suspicion that the person has committed a Schedule 1 crime. The police may not conduct a search without a warrant or consent unless the search is incident to arrest or if the search falls within an exception to the warrant requirement.

    Reasonable suspicion:

    Reasonable suspicion is a lower standard than probable cause. A police officer may arrest a person if the officer has a reasonable suspicion that the person has committed a Schedule 1 crime. The officer can search the person if the officer has reasonable suspicion that the person has a weapon or evidence of the crime.

    Consent:

    A search must be conducted pursuant to a warrant or with consent. A police officer may not search a person without a warrant or consent unless the search is incident to arrest or if the search falls within an exception to the warrant requirement.

    You can sue the SAPS or the Minister of Police, but you must give written notice of your intention to do so within six months of the claim arising. The notice must be delivered to the person by hand or by email.

    You have 3 years to institute a civil action against the Minister in court, starting 90 days after you serve notice of the intended legal proceedings.

    The Minister of Police may be held liable for the following:

    • Bodily injuries, which could include claims for past and future medical expenses, past and future loss of earnings and for pain, suffering and disfigurement

    • Loss of support and/or funeral expenses where a breadwinner passes away as a result of injuries sustained.

    To prove an unlawful arrest claim, you will need to provide evidence that you were arrested without probable cause or based on a violation of your constitutional rights. This can include eyewitness testimony, video footage, police reports, and other documentation related to the arrest.

    If you have been wrongfully arrested, you may be able to recover damages for any physical injuries you sustained during the arrest, as well as any emotional distress, lost wages, or other expenses you incurred as a result of the arrest.

Duane Marais Attorneys Sentencing
  • Once convicted of a crime, and Accused will obtain a criminal record. Sentencing occurs after an Accused person was found guilty / convicted of committing a crime.

    Sentencing has various forms, including: imprisonment, suspended sentences, paying fines, compensating victims etc.

Duane Marais Attorneys Appeal and Review Applications
  • Criminal appeal and Review proceedings usually occurs after conviction and / or sentencing.

    These applications can be brought against the conviction as a whole or certain charges that forms part of the charge sheet or against the sentence as a whole or parts thereof.

Duane Marais Attorneys Mediation
  • Criminal mediation is a procedure introduced to the criminal justice system, whereby parties mediate and agree certain terms and conditions, to strike a balance between avoiding prosecution and compensating a victim of crime.

Duane Marais Attorneys Reckless and Negligent Driving
  • Reckless or negligent driving occurs when a driver operates a motor vehicle in a deliberate or wanton manner, endangering other people or property. Section 63 of the National Road Traffic Act 93 of 1996 defines this behavior as a road traffic offence.

    Negligent driving refers to when a driver does not use proper care while driving a motor vehicle, which can often lead to personal injuries or damage to other vehicles. With the high number of deaths that occur each year as a result of reckless and negligent driving in South Africa, many people and authorities have called on the National Prosecuting Authority to enforce stricter penalties for such drivers.

    You can be arrested on the spot for the following:

    • Exceeding the speed limit by more than 30 km/h in an urban area

    • Exceeding the speed limit by more than 40 km/h outside an urban area or on a freeway

    • Reckless or Negligent Driving

    • Driving under the influence of alcohol or a drug having a narcotic effect

    • Excessive overloading

    • Fraudulent license, license disk or number plates

    • Absence of number plates

    Reckless Driving

    Reckless driving encompasses any driving behavior that flouts the rules of the road and endangers the safety of other motorists and pedestrians. Drivers who engage in reckless driving know full well the risks their actions pose, but continue to drive in a dangerous manner anyway.

    Reckless driving can take many forms, such as speeding in school zones, running red lights, or weaving in and out of traffic. Oftentimes, reckless driving results in costly fines, the loss of driving privileges, and in some cases, jail time. Some examples of reckless driving include:

    • Driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs

    • Excessive speeding

    • Running red lights

    • Drag racing

    • Driving on a sidewalk

    • Texting while driving

    • Failing to yield to or evading a police officer

    Negligent Driving

    Negligence is a legal theory that is used to hold people accountable when their careless actions cause harm to others. When a person is driving, they are expected to use a reasonable amount of care to avoid harming other people.

    If they fail to do so and cause an accident, they can be held liable for any resulting injuries or damage. Some examples of negligent driver behaviors include:

    • Speeding

    • Failing to yield the right of way

    • Disobeying traffic signals

    • Distracted driving

    • Falling asleep at the wheel

    Suing A Defendant For Negligent & Reckless Driving

    Road traffic offences can include speeding, drinking and driving, driving without a license or insurance, dangerous or careless driving etc. Each offence has different possible penalties attached to it. For example, speeding can lead to a fine, while drink driving can lead to a prison sentence. The severity of the penalty will depend on the severity of the offence and the offender‘s driving history.

    If you’ve been seriously injured in a car accident, then you may be entitled to compensation for your injuries. The amount of compensation you may receive, and the legal strategy you pursue, could be influenced by the defendant’s actions. A large damages award is more likely in a reckless driving case than a negligent driving case because the driver’s behavior was more likely to cause serious injury. Additionally, there may be an opportunity for a punitive damages recovery in a reckless driving case.